Okay I should know the answer and my heart calls for CN since we were there last August.
My wife asked me last night if we wanted to go back to Jamaica (no brainer-- I buy red stripe weekly, found ting at a Caribbean store, and haven't taken off my Rasta beads in 8 months), only issue is she really wants to try someting new.

We are mainly about the beach so its gotta be Negril.

Question for the experts who have been to both:

Will CSA fill our hearts like CN did? Or will we long for CN?
Let the loyalty war start...